Featured Product
This Week in Quality Digest Live
Metrology Features
Mark Hembree
Is collaboration overrated?
Belinda Jones
Reaping the benefits of manufacturing intelligence
Nisan Lerea
The method delivers clean, readily inspectable specimens while preserving the original properties of the material being tested
Emily Newton
As demand for PCBs increase, so does the need for faster, comprehensive testing

More Features

Metrology News
Delivers new benchmark in modularity, performance, robustness, and expandability
New lines improve software capability and analysis
VSL hosts special edition of show at new center in Rotterdam
Latest line touts comprehensive coverage, ease of use
Same price, double the resolution and accuracy
Former service partner provides honing and deep-hole drilling solutions
Redesigned family of heavy-duty shop stands delivers unprecedented metrology instrument mobility
Diagnoses LVDT failures, disconnects, or short circuits

More News

Tim Mouw

Metrology

Color Measurement for Metal Packaging Manufacturers

Visual evaluation isn’t enough

Published: Monday, November 28, 2022 - 12:02

Metallized substrates such as two-piece metal packaging are expensive to produce, and they make print color-control challenging. Although many in the metal decorating sector are hesitant to embrace color measurement, it’s the fastest, most accurate, and cost-effective way to produce consistent color across processing plants to achieve sustainability initiatives.

In this article, we’ll discuss the shortcomings of visual evaluation in a color control program, the components of a digital color solution for metal packaging, and how to determine which color measurement device is best for measuring color on metallic substrates.

First, for those resistant to using color measurement, you can see the results of a beverage can gauge R&R study completed by X-Rite in 2020 that confirms the accuracy and repeatability of an X-Rite digital color solution in a beverage can manufacturing environment. In short, the study confirmed that there was no significant variation due to the instrument’s variability or the process of repositioning and remeasuring a can. Also, it showed that there is zero probability that a part would be misclassified as either good or bad.

Color Measurement for Metal Packaging
Operators from a beverage can production crew with varying experience were chosen to measure cans using the X-Rite Ci64 spectrophotometer and a sample holding fixture to measure printed metal beverage cans in the round.

Why visual evaluation isn’t sufficient to evaluate color accuracy

Three things are required to see color: our eyes, light, and the object. All three are subject to variability.

Variations in the human eye: Genetics, color memory, eye fatigue, color blindness, and medications are just some of the variables that affect our ability to distinguish color differences. Also, we all see color a little differently, which leads to disagreement between operators and shifts.

Variations in the type of light: Light has the biggest effect on the colors we see. The visible color spectrum—what we know as the rainbow (RGBIV)—encompasses light wavelengths from approximately 400 to 700 nanometers and breaks down into three primary colors: red, green, and blue. Each type of light, such as incandescent, fluorescent, and daylight, has a different mix of wavelengths and therefore shines a different type of light.

The reflection of the object: Objects themselves don’t have color. They have properties that determine which wavelengths of light are absorbed and which are reflected. It is the mixture of the reflected light that enters our eyes and gives us the perception of color. When the type of light changes, such as between fluorescent factory lighting and daylight, the amount of light that reflects off the object—and the resulting color—also changes.

Color Measurement for Metal Packaging
While the car above looks red under noon daylight, it appears bluer under the night sky, and more yellow under fluorescent and horizon sunlight. However, without a point of reference, they all just look red.

Visual evaluation on reflective surfaces is nearly impossible. If you hold the package one way, the color may look acceptable, but if you turn it to the side or step into the sun, the color changes. Although it may pass in your opinion, will the brand owner see it the same way? Will the final color match the companion packaging on the store shelf?

X-Rite's popular Color Perception blog series covers this topic in greater detail, but the key takeaway is that visual evaluation is prone to subjectivity. When cost and suitability drive your bottom line, visual evaluation alone isn’t the most cost-effective or reproducible way to evaluate color.

The components of a digital color workflow

The only tangible way to ensure accurate color across multiple sites is with digital specification and evaluation—that is, using digital values for color in conjunction with physical references. Once the emphasis of color evaluation shifts from a physical reference to a known digital value, everyone can do a better job of achieving the color of the original design.

To control color on metallized surfaces, your workflow doesn’t have to change much. You might just need some new tools.
• A color measurement device: Taking spectral measurements will help you spot-check production samples to ensure color remains in tolerance throughout each run.
• Quality control software: By entering the digital specification for the standard and the acceptable dE tolerance, you can use the digital data from the color measurement device to immediately determine if your color is on target. You can also track trends and report color compliance back to brands.

Color Measurement for Metal Packaging


Choosing the best device for measuring color on metallic substrates

45:0 spectrophotometers are typically used for packaging applications. In these instruments, the illumination of the sample is from 45° (45° from the sample surface), and the specular or gloss angle—the angle at which the light is directly reflected—is also 45°. Since the pickup is at 0° from the surface, it can’t pick up the gloss. When dealing with reflective packaging, this isn’t the best instrument for the job.

For reflective packaging, a sphere spectrophotometer is the preferred instrument because it provides diffuse illumination. The wall is coated in a highly reflective white surface, and the light source is located on the rear of a sphere with a baffle to prevent the light from directly illuminating the sample. With a sphere instrument, the sample and gloss angle are both viewed at 8° from perpendicular. The reference beam port monitors the sphere wall to account for changes in illumination.

A sphere spectrophotometer can provide reflectance measurements in two ways: specular included (SPIN) and specular excluded (SPEX). To include gloss in the measurement, the specular port closes. To exclude gloss, the specular port opens so the specular component isn’t included in the measurement.

 Diagram  Description automatically generated

Believe it or not, it’s possible to achieve a perfect digital match in either the specular included or specular excluded component, but a complete mismatch in terms of the visual color. For metallic packaging, it’s best to capture both the specular included and specular excluded components together as reflectance, or lack thereof, for a better impression of the color.

An X-Rite solution to measure color on metal cans

X-Rite’s solution to measure color on metal cans includes:

Ci64
Ci64 sphere spectrophotometer: As X-Rite’s most precise handheld sphere spectrophotometer, the Ci64 offers reliable data collection and statistical process control with simultaneous SPIN/SPEX and correlated gloss. A graphical jobs interface and configurable menus enable operators to view measurement procedures and data directly from the device for consistency across shifts, production lines, and manufacturing facilities.

Cup Cylinder
Cup and cylinder fixture: The cup and cylinder fixture has a sample-positioning arm to hold an unnecked beverage can and a bench to hold the Ci64 at the correct height and angle for consistent measurements at multiple orientations without deformation or distortion.

Color iQC
Color iQC software: Color iQC is a configurable, job-based software system to easily evaluate whether a measured sample is in tolerance of the standard. With Color iQC, brands, suppliers, and manufacturers can define standards, tolerances, settings, and measurement modes to ensure correct color measurement practices between operators and across locations.

Netprofiler 3
NetProfiler software: NetProfiler is a cloud-based blend of software and color standards that makes it easy to adjust and validate instrument performance, identify instruments in need of service, and reduce variation between devices.

But perhaps the best part of an X-Rite solution is the support you’ll receive from our color experts. We offer onsite consultation and training as well as certification programs to maximize your color measurement process.

Learn more

Download X-Rite’s “Color Measurement and Tolerancing for Two-Piece Metal Packaging” whitepaper to learn how an X-Rite color measurement solution is repeatable and reproducible for a consistent measurement process with less waste.

If you’d like to learn more about how Coca-Cola Europe is using X-Rite solutions to address packaging sustainability, read this blog.

Visit X-Rite to browse an extensive library of resources or get in touch with one of X-Rite’s color experts to discuss your specific needs.

Discuss

About The Author

Tim Mouw’s picture

Tim Mouw

Tim Mouw is the manager of applications engineering and technical support for X-Rite Pantone in the Americas. Mouw oversees a team of 20 technical support specialists who help customers manage and improve color quality control processes, and has taught more than 300 color science courses throughout North and South America, Europe, Asia, and Australia. X-Rite helps customers communicate and manage color standards for raw materials, paper-based products, ink, photography, video, metal, glass, textiles, plastics, and wood.