Featured Product
This Week in Quality Digest Live
Innovation Features
Matt Fieldman
Through grants and best practices, America Works strives to define it
UC Berkeley NewsCenter
Important confirmation that scale-up will work
Hexagon Manufacturing Intelligence
Open software platform enables nonspecialists to code and control any industrial robot to democratize industrial automation
Emily Newton
Consumers want to know that EVs are safe and reliable
Ryan E. Day
What will you teach your drone to do?

More Features

Innovation News
The tabletop diagnostic yields results in an hour and can be programmed to detect variants of the SARS-CoV-2 virus
First Responder UAS Triple Challenge focuses on using optical sensors and data analysis to improve image detection and location
More than half of respondents expect to meet Industry 4.0 goals within two years
Both quality professionals and their business leaders agree that openness and communication is essential to moving forward
Voxel8 patented technology will provide printed lattice structures to be used as inserts in midsoles
Purpose-built for cannabis analysis
True 3D holographic displays are practical with only moderate computational requirements
Inspect nozzle welds using phased array ultrasound testing techniques including ray-tracing, scanner simulation, coverage maps
Produce large parts up to 300 × 300 × 450 mm without residual stress, gas cross flow, or having to pre-sinter powder bed

More News

NIST

Innovation

Cold Hard Facts of Metrology

Temperature control vital to vaccine viability

Published: Monday, February 1, 2016 - 17:37

Flu season typically peaks between December and February, but by the time the winter holidays roll around, many of us will have already waited in line at area clinics, grocery stores, and pharmacies to get our annual flu shot. The Centers for Disease Control reports that U.S. vaccination efforts since 1994 have prevented an estimated 16 million illnesses every year.

Even so, some people choose to avoid vaccination, citing reasons like a lack of confidence in its usefulness, complication risks, or religious beliefs. Some news outlets thrive on the controversy, sensationalizing reports of disease outbreaks, possible vaccine failures, and anti-vaccination propaganda. Yet the public debates have missed a critical factor in vaccine effectiveness: temperature.

That’s right. To work correctly, all vaccines require strict temperature control from the point of manufacture up until they are injected into a patient’s arm. Our work at NIST is helping to ensure that providers know how to maintain vaccines at the right temperatures, so those who get the shot can be confident that every dose works as intended.

Most vaccines administered in the United States must be kept between 2° C and 8° C through a network called the cold chain. Refrigerated vaccines exposed to temperatures outside this allowable range lose their potency. Vaccines that are too warm will eventually spoil, and a single freezing event will cause irreparable damage, rendering the medication entirely useless. A 2007 meta-analysis estimated that as much as 35 percent of the world’s vaccines are subjected to accidental freezing in the cold chain.

Unfortunately, there’s no quick and easy way to determine whether a vaccine has been exposed to inappropriate storage temperatures, which means that ineffective vaccines may be unknowingly administered to patients. Instead, to assess vaccine viability, pharmaceutical manufacturers, distributors, and immunization providers must rely on temperature-monitoring devices placed in temperature-controlled storage units and shipping containers.

The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) plays a major role in managing the U.S. vaccine market through its Vaccines for Children (VFC) program, which distributes nearly $4 billion worth of vaccines to underinsured and underprivileged children each year. More than 44,000 U.S. clinics distribute vaccines through the VFC program, and immunization providers around the country look to the CDC for guidance and policies on the best methods for storing, transporting, and monitoring vaccines under proper, temperature-controlled conditions.

In 2009, the CDC asked the NIST Thermodynamic Metrology Group for help solving problems in temperature measurement and control of vaccines distributed through its VFC program. Wasted vaccines from equipment and temperature-monitoring failures at clinics around the country were adding up to a significant monetary and public health cost. When vaccine temperature excursions are discovered, costly and embarrassing re-vaccination efforts may be needed, which put communities at risk and erode public confidence. Many physicians have expressed frustration at the lack of consistent guidance and information for safely managing their vaccine supplies.

Our group is gradually bridging this knowledge gap through studies designed to replicate the vaccine storage and transport conditions that occur at the provider office level. We study vaccine refrigerators ranging from the cheapest dorm fridge available at your local big box outlet to highly engineered, purpose-built pharmaceutical and laboratory refrigerator systems.

Each of our test refrigerators is filled with vaccines and wired up with a boatload of miniature temperature sensors called thermocouples. They are then subjected to the sorts of conditions we expect to happen in real life—repeated door opening, temperature adjustments, power failures, overloading the unit with large amounts of vaccines, and so on. We test temperature-monitoring devices and setup methods to determine the best way to accurately track stored vaccine temperatures inside a unit without too much effort or expense. We also develop vaccine transport “packout” methods using readily available materials and coolers.

From our results, we provide the CDC with user-friendly guidance on questions like: What type of vaccine refrigerator should I buy? What should I look for in a temperature-monitoring device? How can I calibrate my vaccine refrigerator thermometer? How can I safely transport vaccines in an emergency? How can I best manage power failures?

One of our earliest findings was that dorm-style refrigerators are extremely unsafe for vaccine storage, as they may result in rapid, accidental freezing of vaccine. At the time, these units were commonplace in smaller clinics due to their convenient size and small price tag. Since the NIST findings were published, however, dorm-style units have been removed from all VFC provider offices.

NIST research has generated other major improvements in vaccine-management practices, including widespread use of calibrated, traceable, and continuously recording temperature-monitoring devices inside vaccine refrigerators—phasing out analog devices and handwritten temperature-record sheets. Our studies also highlighted the importance of monitoring stored product temperature instead of air temperature, thereby reducing vaccine waste caused by false temperature alarms.

NIST findings are repackaged and distributed through the CDC’s Vaccine Storage and Handling Toolkit, which vaccine providers, state health department immunization managers, and cold chain equipment manufacturers rely on as the primary guidebook for U.S. vaccine management policies. So if you get the flu shot and don’t get the flu this year, give some credit to CDC, NIST, and a better-working cold chain.

So the next time you hear people arguing about the flu shot, ask what they think about cold chain management practices. It may end the discussion—or prompt a Google search.

First published Jan. 21, 2016, on Taking Measure.

Discuss

About The Author

NIST’s picture

NIST

Founded in 1901, The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) is a nonregulatory federal agency within the U.S. Department of Commerce. Headquartered in Gaithersburg, Maryland, NIST’s mission is to promote U.S. innovation and industrial competitiveness by advancing measurement science, standards, and technology in ways that enhance economic security and improve our quality of life.