Featured Product
This Week in Quality Digest Live
Health Care Features
Gleb Tsipursky
Effective engagement can foster productivity and stronger financials
Clare Naden
One way is through a system of conformity assessment to ISO standards
Maria Church
Stop, pause, and remember what brought you here in the first place
Sheronda Jeffries
Inclusion of ISO 13485 certificates in IAF CertSearch could help protect first responders
Stephen M. Hahn
The FDA examines new ways of building the science to inform public health decisions

More Features

Health Care News
‘Completely new diagnostic platform’ could prove to be a valuable clinical tool for detecting exposure to multiple viruses
Provides improved thermal stability for stored materials, risk mitigation advantages, and processes that are documented and repeatable
Patient safety is a key focus in update of ISO 14155, the industry reference for good practice in clinical trials.
Despite being far from campus because of the pandemic, some students are engineering a creative way to stay connected
Good quality is adding an average of 11 percent to organizations’ revenue growth
Further enhances change management capabilities
Stereotactic robot helps identify target and deliver electrodes to target with submillimetric accuracy
How the nation’s leading multistate cannabis company ensures quality and safety standards
ISO and WHO are working for universal access to quality health products that are all at once safe, effective, and affordable

More News

Thomas Hellwig

Health Care

How to Spot When an Employee Is Secretly Struggling

A three-step ‘emotional triaging’ technique can help identify warning signs of Covid-19 burnout

Published: Tuesday, June 16, 2020 - 11:02

The Covid-19 world is marked by a high degree of uncertainty and existential fear, a dearth of social interaction, the convergence of professional and personal space, a lack of physical activity, and an obsessive focus on hygiene and social distancing. For professionals, this amounts to a toxic combination that elevates stress levels and increases the risk of burnout. Virtually no one—and no organization—is immune.

Now more than ever, managers should become sensitive to the mental health of their teams, not to mention themselves. But few managers have formal training in this arena, which means their ability to directly intervene in the most severe cases is limited. What managers need first and foremost is a set of tools to help identify when an employee is seriously struggling. They can then take appropriate steps to ensure the sufferer has access to the necessary resources before the problem becomes so big that it’s overwhelming.

This sounds straightforward, but it’s actually a complex and delicate matter. Especially during the early stages of burnout, people are reluctant to be emotionally open with their manager for fear of being judged a “stressed-out employee.” For a manager to approach the issue head-on with blunt questions may backfire. Therefore, we advocate for a three-step system that we call “emotional triaging.”

1. Check in with the team

Several studies indicate that group emotions have a direct effect on group behavior, with regards to cooperation and performance, but evaluating these emotions must be done according to good professional standards. Checking in is an intentional practice for a team to start a meeting. When the team is aware of potential personal distractions, it’s easier to focus on the primary task or project itself. Checking in increases self-awareness and the cohesion of teams as members become less judgmental. Be aware that certain team members, such as introverts, outsiders, or junior employees, might struggle more in sharing.

We suggest a pragmatic approach for emotional checking in that can work even in the virtual space. Ask team members to self-evaluate on a scale of 1 to 10 (e.g., via a Zoom poll) in response to questions such as, “What is your energy level? What is your stress level in the current working environment?” Adding one or two explorative questions can give further insights into the emotional well-being of the team. For example: “What are the three challenges you consider the most important to address at the moment for you and the team?”

2. Individual deep dives

However, some employees might still feel intimidated. Drawing them out will require individual attention and sensitivity. Hence, we suggest including deep dives as part of regular conversations. The objective is to explore further for early signs of stress. Avoid directly asking, “Are you stressed?” because this might trigger a denial or defensive behavior. A better way to start is to be open about how stress is affecting you, establishing from the outset that the topic is not taboo. This shows vulnerability and triggers reciprocity in others.

From there, consider asking open questions such as “How do you manage your current workload, tons of emails, and the virtual work? What do you consider as the main challenges in the current situation?” These general questions can start a short discussion in which you can explore potential stressors.

These virtual conversations are much better managed if both parties have audio and video enabled. That way, you can pick up on red flags in the employee’s body language.

In scanning for early warning signs, managers can use our “Stress APGAR” framework to evaluate stress levels:
Appearance: Visibly evident sleep disturbance, dejected posture, and bodily pain (physical)
Performance: Impairment of cognitive performance due to time pressure, information overload, and uncertainty (mental)
Growth: Loss of a sense of purpose, direction, and hope for a better future (spiritual)
Affect control: Uncontrolled outbursts and irritability (emotional)
Relationships: Deterioration of relationships and social isolation (social)

In contrast to the original APGAR (a well-known health-scoring method from neonatal medicine), the Stress APGAR is not an assessment tool but rather a guide for managers to ask the right questions. For example, managers can consider asking:
Appearance: How do you keep your energy up? How are your sleeping patterns? How do you maintain your physical and mental fitness?
Performance: How do you cope with the workload at the moment? How do you manage the performance pressures we face?
Growth: What gives you purpose and meaning at the moment? What are your and your team’s development objectives?
Affect control: How do you cope with frustration? Do you get easily upset or incensed when discussing work issues or personal topics?
Relationships: How do you experience your key relationships at work? Do you ask for and accept help from others?

Our Stress APGAR framework can be incorporated into your usual one-to-one conversations, especially with colleagues you are already concerned about.

3. Show compassion and know your limits

In the last step of emotional triaging, you need to consider appropriate actions.

Some team members already have a strong coping mechanism in place. Take care not to favor them above others who are having a tougher time. Instead, use them wisely as a possible source of help for their stressed-out peers, either through coaching or relieving colleagues of tasks that might be adding stress.  

Stress sufferers can be separated into two categories based on the Stress APGAR framework. People who satisfy at least two of the five criteria should receive more of your time and attention. You should especially be concerned if you recognize some unhelpful coping mechanisms such as ignoring individual issues (denial), inability to ask for and accept help (heroism), and the tendency to protect others at their own expense (helper syndrome). You must remain in closer contact with these workers and strongly encourage them to access resources for help, such as mental health professionals.

Employees who meet only one or none of the Stress APGAR conditions may be regarded as minor cases whose stress management can perhaps be sufficiently improved by the compassion and support you can provide. They are still at risk, however, especially if they are either unaware or unable to seek support (e.g., overloaded agenda and professional/personal life conflicts).

Beyond the crisis

Covid-19 is a literal stress test for individuals, teams, and organizations everywhere. The current crisis challenges managers to rapidly and radically increase their mental health awareness so that they can prevent their teams from being defeated by stress. Practices such as the above, if they are continued after the pandemic passes, can help companies and managers remain at that high level of awareness.

First published June 1, 2020, on INSEAD’s Knowledge blog.


About The Author

Thomas Hellwig’s picture

Thomas Hellwig

Thomas Hellwig is an adjunct professor at INSEAD. He works as an independent consultant, executive coach, and a program director. His recent teaching and research focus on change management, coaching effectiveness, and health and stress manaement